Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?

Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?

Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?
Even the most sophisticated AI systems are only as good as the data they’re fed. (Shutterstock image)
Short Url

Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?In the bustling metropolis of Techville, where neon-lit skyscrapers and algorithm-driven traffic lights rule the streets, the latest buzz isn’t about the newest gadget or the trendiest AI companion. No, the citizens of Techville are grappling with a weightier issue — democracy and how AI might be its ruin or its savior.

The idea that AI could one day manage democracies has moved from science fiction to serious discourse in Techville’s coffee shops and university halls. Over a latte, the city’s philosophers debate whether AI could enhance the democratic process or if it’s a slippery slope toward technocratic tyranny.

The great expert on democracies, a figure whose name you’ll hear whispered with a mix of reverence and concern, once said: “Their worst enemy is the inequality between rich and poor.” It’s hard to imagine how a silicon-based overlord, devoid of human emotion, could tackle such a deeply human issue. Yet, here we are, asking: Could AI help resolve the growing chasm between the haves and the have-nots, or will it merely exacerbate it?

Let’s start with the concerns. Erica Benner, political philosopher and author of Adventures in Democracy, has much to say on the matter. “The dangers that threaten our political system are multifaceted,” she warns. And before you think she’s about to extol the virtues of a well-educated electorate, Benner throws us a curveball. “The solution,” she argues, “is not necessarily to have more educated citizens.”

Benner’s argument is both refreshing and unsettling. She suggests that the problem isn’t just the voters, but the very framework of democracy itself. In an AI-managed democracy, the risk isn’t just that the uneducated masses might be swayed by clever algorithms. The bigger issue is that AI could institutionalize biases, effectively cementing existing inequalities. In other words, the system that should be freeing us could end up shackling us in new ways.

Imagine an AI, designed to maximize efficiency and stability, which determines that the best way to run a country is by reinforcing the status quo. If the rich are happy, and the poor are pacified with just enough resources to keep them quiet, why change anything? The inequality that our democracy expert warned about could become a permanent feature — no longer a bug, but an intentional design choice.

There’s a certain allure to the idea of AI-driven governance. Algorithms, after all, aren’t susceptible to bribes, they don’t get tired, and they don’t have a stake in the next election cycle.

Rafael Hernandez de Santiago

But let’s not throw the AI out with the bathwater just yet. The optimists in Techville have a different vision. They see AI as the tool that could finally perfect democracy, eliminating corruption, inefficiency, and perhaps even the inequality that plagues our current systems. In a city where even the street sweepers discuss Kant over their morning coffee, the idea of an AI philosopher-king doesn’t seem so far-fetched.

There’s a certain allure to the idea of AI-driven governance. Algorithms, after all, aren’t susceptible to bribes, they don’t get tired, and they don’t have a stake in the next election cycle. “Imagine a world where policies are based purely on data,” muses one of Techville’s more starry-eyed tech entrepreneurs, “where decisions are made without the messy business of human emotions and biases.”

Yet, even the most sophisticated AI systems are only as good as the data they’re fed. And as any Techvillian worth their coding skills will tell you, data can be messy, biased, and incomplete. The irony here is rich. The very tools that promise to perfect democracy could end up corrupting it from within, not through malice or intent, but through the cold, unfeeling logic that AI thrives on.

Techville’s streets may be clean, and its governance hyper-efficient, but beneath the surface, the philosophical debate rages on. Can a democracy managed by AI truly be democratic? Or would it be democracy in name only, with the real power held by the engineers and data scientists behind the curtain?

There’s a delicious irony in the fact that the very tools we’ve created to serve us might end up ruling us instead. As Benner wryly notes in Adventures in Democracy: “Perhaps the greatest adventure of all is the one where we realize that the map we’ve been following leads us right back to where we started.”

In a city where irony is the local dialect and debate a civic duty, the discussion is far from over. Should we reinvent democracy to include our new AI overlords? Or should we be cautious, remembering that the tools we build to solve our problems often create new ones in their wake?

One thing is clear. Democracy, like any good piece of technology, might need a few updates. But whether those updates should be coded by humans or by AI is a question that even the smartest bots in Techville have yet to answer.

Rafael Hernandez de Santiago, viscount of Espes, is a Spanish national residing in Saudi Arabia and working at the Gulf Research Center.


 

Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not necessarily reflect Arab News' point of view

Pakistan court orders arrest of senior police officers accused of staging blasphemy suspect’s murder

Pakistan court orders arrest of senior police officers accused of staging blasphemy suspect’s murder
Updated 9 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan court orders arrest of senior police officers accused of staging blasphemy suspect’s murder

Pakistan court orders arrest of senior police officers accused of staging blasphemy suspect’s murder
  • Shahnawaz Kunbhar, a medical doctor accused of online blasphemy, was killed by police in an encounter in September
  • Government inquiry later said officers, including a deputy inspector general of police, had staged the encounter

KARACHI: An anti-terrorism court (ATC) in Pakistan’s Sindh province this week issued arrest warrants for six police officers, including a deputy inspector general of police, over accusations they had staged the murder of a doctor accused of blasphemy, but the suspects had not yet been arrested, his family said on Friday.

Dr. Shahnawaz Kunbhar, accused of sharing blasphemous content online, was arrested in Karachi and killed by police in Mirpurkhas on Sept. 18, 2024. Police said the killing was unintentional and happened when officers attempted to stop two men on a motorcycle, and one of them started shoooting, prompting them to return fire. Authorities said it was only after the shooting that they realized the man they had killed was the doctor they had been seeking in a blasphemy case. 

Mass protests in Sindh province and widespread social media outrage followed the doctor’s killing, leading to the formation of a government committee that concluded that Kunbhar was killed in a “staged encounter.” The Sindh provincial government subsequently suspended 10 officers, including a deputy inspector general, and filed charges against 34 suspects. It is rare in Pakistan for government action over violence against people accused of blasphemy. 

Ibrahim Kunbhar, the cousin of the deceased, confirmed to Arab News that the ATC had issued non-bailable arrest warrants for six officers, including former DIG Javed Jiskani, on Thursday. 

“But why do they need non-bailable arrest warrants to apprehend them? They should have been arrested long ago as their guilt has been proven in the official inquiry,” Ibrahim said in a telephone interview on Friday. “We demand that they be immediately apprehended and tried for the murder of Shahnawaz.”

The court also ordered the Federal Investigation Agency to present the accused officers before the court by January 8, 2025. Ibrahim said the FIA had recorded statements from five medical board members who exhumed Kunbhar’s body. One of them, Professor Dr. Waheed, confirmed signs of “torture,” including five broken ribs.

Accusations of blasphemy, sometimes even just rumors, can spark riots and mob rampages in Pakistan. Although killings of suspects by mobs are common, extra-judicial killings by police are rare, as is action against perpetrators of violence in blasphemy cases. 

Human rights groups and civil society organizations have urged the Pakistani government to repeal the country’s blasphemy laws, which they argue contribute to discrimination and violence. They have also called for a comprehensive review of law enforcers’ response to blasphemy accusations.
 


Australia announces $118 million deal to enhance policing in Solomon Islands

Australia announces $118 million deal to enhance policing in Solomon Islands
Updated 7 min 48 sec ago
Follow

Australia announces $118 million deal to enhance policing in Solomon Islands

Australia announces $118 million deal to enhance policing in Solomon Islands
  • Australia has been energetically pursuing new bilateral security deals with its Pacific island neighbors
  • Beijing and the Solomons signed a security deal in 2022 under prime minister’s Jeremiah Manele’s predecessor

MELBOURNE: Australia announced on Friday it will pay for more police in Solomon Islands and create a police training center in the South Pacific island nation’s capital Honiara, where Chinese law enforcement instructors are already based under a bilateral security pact with Beijing.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said Australia would spend $118 million (190 million Australian dollars) over four years on funding and training new Royal Solomon Islands Police Force recruits with a package that would “reduce any need for outside support.”
“My government is proud to make a significant investment in the police force of the Solomon Islands to ensure that they can continue to take primary responsibility for security in the Solomons,” Albanese told reporters in Australia’s capital Canberra.
Albanese and his Solomons counterpart Jeremiah Manele said in a joint statement on Friday the package would build an enduring security capability in the Solomons, “thereby reducing its reliance on external partners over time.”
Australia has been energetically pursuing new bilateral security deals with its Pacific island neighbors since Beijing and the Solomons signed a security deal in 2022 under Manele’s predecessor, Manasseh Sogavare.
That deal has created fears among US allies including Australia that the Chinese navy will be allowed to build a base in the strategically important Solomons.
Albanese’s Labour Party, which was the opposition at the time the pact was signed, described it as Australia’s worst foreign policy failure in the Pacific since World War II.
Australia has recently signed security deals with Papua New Guinea, Tuvalu and Nauru that effectively give Canberra veto powers over any security deals those countries might want to strike with third nations including China.
Asked if the new deal would require the Chinese security presence to be removed from the Solomons, Albanese did not directly answer.
“The Solomon Islands of course is a sovereign nation. They have some measures in place and we expect that to continue,” Albanese said.
“As a result of this agreement, what we’ve done is make sure that Australia remains the security partner of choice,” he added.
Mihai Sora, a Pacific islands expert at the Lowy Institute, a Sydney-based international policy think tank, said the agreement was a “clear win for Solomon Islands, which has gained a much-needed boost to its law and justice sector.”
“But Solomon Islands has not committed to scaling back the essentially permanent rotating presence of around 14 Chinese police trainers in the country, who have been running their own parallel training program with Solomon Islands police since 2022,” Sora said in an email.
“So, the agreement falls short of a solid strategic commitment to Australia from Solomon Islands, and there’s no indication that it would derail China-Solomon Islands security ties,” Sora added.
Blake Johnson, an analyst at the Australian Security Policy Institute, a Canberra-based think tank, said Chinese policing in the Pacific gives Beijing tools to control Chinese expatriates and pursue other goals.
“They can be very heavy-handed in their response sometimes. There are also concerns around data and privacy risks associated with Chinese police in the region,” Johnson said.
“Sometimes they’re providing surveillance equipment. There are concerns about what that is being used for and what it’s capturing,” he added.


Pakistan joins world leaders in condemnation of Israel on D-8 summit sidelines

Pakistan joins world leaders in condemnation of Israel on D-8 summit sidelines
Updated 19 min 27 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan joins world leaders in condemnation of Israel on D-8 summit sidelines

Pakistan joins world leaders in condemnation of Israel on D-8 summit sidelines
  • Pakistani PM Sharif, Turkish President Erdogan and Iranian President Pezeshkian discuss Gaza in separate meetings
  • More than 46,000 people including women and children have been killed during the 14-month war in Palestine

ISLAMABAD: Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has joined world leaders in condemning Israel’s ongoing military offensives in the Middle East as he attended a summit of D-98 developing nations in Cairo this week, his office said. 

On the sidelines of the forum, Sharif separately met Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian after a special session was held on the conflict in the Middle East, where over 46,000 Palestinians, more than half of them women and children, have been killed since Israel launched its war against Hamas in Gaza in October last year. Israel has since carried out attacks on Lebanon as well, killing over 3,000 after accusing Hezbollah of targeting its military. This month, it took control of Syria’s buffer zone and bombed key military and strategic assets after the overthrow of the Bashar Assad regime by opposition forces.

“While condemning the Israeli genocidal actions against the innocent Palestinians, particularly the worsening situation since Oct. 7, 2023, the two leaders reaffirmed their unwavering support for the Palestinian people and their legitimate aspirations for a promised homeland,” Sharif’s office said in a statement after he held a bilateral meeting with Erdogan.

Sharif also separately met with Pezeshkian on the sidelines of the D-8 summit.

“Both leaders showed grave concern at the genocide of innocent Palestinians by Israel and agreed to continue raising their voice for the oppressed Palestinians,” the PM Office said in another press release. “The PM reiterated that Pakistan stands in complete solidarity with their brothers and sisters from Palestine, Lebanon and Syria.”

Since the beginning of Israel’s war on Gaza, Pakistan has repeatedly raised the issue at the United Nations, the Organization of Islamic Cooperation and other multilateral platforms and demanded international powers and bodies stop Israeli military actions. 

Islamabad does not have diplomatic relations with Israel and has for decades called for an independent Palestinian state with Al-Quds Al-Sharif as its capital.


Japan inspects US air base over chemical spill

Japan inspects US air base over chemical spill
Updated 25 min 20 sec ago
Follow

Japan inspects US air base over chemical spill

Japan inspects US air base over chemical spill
  • Japan’s probe follows US notice two months ago that water containing PFOS had spilled from the site

TOKYO: Japanese authorities on Friday staged an inspection of a US military base in Tokyo, a government spokesman said, after being informed by the American side of a chemical leak.
Japan’s probe at the Yokota Air Base followed a US notice two months ago that water containing PFOS — classified by the World Health Organization as “possibly carcinogenic to humans” — had spilled from the site.
PFOS is part of a large group of man-made chemicals known as PFAS, sometimes called “forever chemicals” because they do not degrade easily, experts say.
The US military informed Tokyo in October that the PFOS-laced water had leaked from an area of the base where a fire-fighting drill was being carried out, Fumitoshi Sato, deputy chief cabinet secretary, told reporters.
“This inspection was realized in response to the fears and concerns harbored by local residents, and we will continue to work together with the US side,” Sato said.
Officials including from the defense ministry and Tokyo’s metropolitan government visited the site on Friday, he said. Yokota Air Base was not immediately available for comment.
America’s military presence in Japan has frequently stoked local discontent in the past, with everything from noise to pollution to helicopter accidents.
This frustration is perhaps most evident on the southern island of Okinawa, which despite comprising just 0.6 percent of Japan’s landmass, hosts the vast majority of the country’s US military bases.
Okinawa is located east of Taiwan, a flashpoint for tensions between the United States and China.
Earlier this month, the United States began relocating thousands of Marines from Okinawa, with an initial “detachment of approximately 100 logistics support Marines” transferred to the US island territory of Guam.


Canada’s Trudeau to shuffle his Cabinet amid resignation calls and rising discontent

Canada’s Trudeau to shuffle his Cabinet amid resignation calls and rising discontent
Updated 30 min 13 sec ago
Follow

Canada’s Trudeau to shuffle his Cabinet amid resignation calls and rising discontent

Canada’s Trudeau to shuffle his Cabinet amid resignation calls and rising discontent
  • Trudeau is facing rising discontent over his leadership
  • Rising number of Liberal lawmakers are calling on Trudeau to resign

TORONTO: Embattled Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will shuffle his Cabinet Friday.
The prime minister’s office confirmed late Thursday that Trudeau will participate in the swearing-in ceremony and chair a meeting with his new Cabinet later Friday.
Trudeau is facing rising discontent over his leadership, and the abrupt departure of his finance minister on Monday could be something he can’t recover from.
A rising number of Liberal lawmakers are calling on Trudeau to resign but new Finance Minister Dominic LeBlanc said Thursday Trudeau has the “full support of his Cabinet.”
LeBlanc said he respects the views of Liberal lawmakers who want Trudeau to resign.
“That’s a view they are expressing. The prime minister listened carefully when that view was expressed to him,” LeBlanc said. “He listened, in some cases responded to specific things that were raised, and he said he would reflect carefully.”
LeBlanc said the government will remain focused on work and addressing the threat by President-elect Donald Trump to impose a 25 percent tariff on all Canadian products when he is inaugurated next month.
“We shouldn’t be looking inward. We shouldn’t be worrying about ourselves,” LeBlanc said.
LeBlanc said he will meet with Tom Homan, Trump’s incoming “border czar,” after Christmas to discuss Canada’s plan to secure the border as part of a bid to avoid the tariffs.
Trudeau has led the country for nearly a decade, but has become widely unpopular in recent years over a wide range of issues, including the high cost of living and rising inflation.
There is no mechanism for Trudeau’s party to force him out in the short term. He could resign, or his Liberal party could be forced from power by a “no confidence” vote in Parliament that would trigger an election that would very likely favor the opposing Conservative Party.
As rising numbers of Liberal lawmakers called for Trudeau to resign this week, Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson said, “We all need to give him a little time to reflect.”
Concerns about Trudeau’s leadership were exacerbated Monday when Chrystia Freeland, Trudeau’s finance minister and deputy prime minister, resigned from the Cabinet. Freeland was highly critical of Trudeau’s handling of the economy in the face of steep tariffs threatened by Trump. Shortly before Freeland announced her decision, the housing minister also quit.
Because Trudeau’s Liberals don’t hold an outright majority in the Parliament, they have for years depended on the support of the leftist New Democratic Party to pass legislation and stay in power. But that support has all but vanished — the NDP’s leader has called on Trudeau to resign — and that might clear the way for Parliament to vote “no confidence.”
NDP leader Jagmeet Singh, however, would not commit to bringing down the government at the first opportunity in part because Trump could impose crippling tariffs and Parliament might need to respond with tariffs in retaliation.
Parliament is now shut for the holidays until late next month, and a “no confidence” vote could be scheduled sometime thereafter.
“It appears Trudeau will be stepping down, but no one knows exactly when,” said Nelson Wiseman, professor emeritus at the University of Toronto. “The need to fill vacant posts and to relieve some ministers of carrying multiple portfolios is the drive behind the shuffle but it will not boost the Liberal party’s polling numbers; it’s too late in the day for that to happen.”
LeBlanc also said Mark Carney won’t be joining Cabinet. Trudeau has been trying to recruit Carney, the former head of the Bank of England and Bank of Canada, to join his government. Carney has long been interested in entering politics and becoming the leader of the Liberal Party.
“Mr. Carney isn’t about to become Canada’s finance minister in the short term,” LeBlanc said. “The prime minister asked me to start that work and to get ready for a budget in the spring.”