Bayesian tragedy coverage exposes ‘double standards’: Refugee NGOs

Bayesian tragedy coverage exposes ‘double standards’: Refugee NGOs
The investigation into the sinking of the superyacht Bayesian, which sank off Sicily's coast, is widening to include the crew. (File/AP)
Short Url
Updated 29 August 2024
Follow

Bayesian tragedy coverage exposes ‘double standards’: Refugee NGOs

Bayesian tragedy coverage exposes ‘double standards’: Refugee NGOs
  • ‘Jarring contrast’ between superyacht, refugee vessel rescue efforts
  • ‘Sadly, it makes a difference in the media, in our society and in politics, who is drowning’

LONDON: European NGOs have decried the “double standards” of global media attention given to the Bayesian superyacht tragedy compared to refugee ship rescue attempts.

The luxury vessel was hit by a violent storm off the Sicilian coast on Aug. 19, resulting in the deaths of seven people, including British tech magnate Mike Lynch.

The incident received worldwide media coverage and significant resources were given to rescue efforts.

But NGOs have told The Guardian of a “jarring contrast” between attention given to the Bayesian story and those of regular refugee boat disasters.

Sea-Eye, a German humanitarian organization, said in a statement: “For us, every death in the Mediterranean is one too many, no matter where they come from or how much money they make.”

The organization’s most recent mission involved the rescue of 262 people. “Sadly, it makes a difference in the media, in our society and in politics, who is drowning,” Sea-Eye told The Guardian.

“We have noticed that the coverage of the situation in the Mediterranean, of tragedies or of our rescues in recent months has not been nearly as extensive as in the case of the Sicilian shipwreck in recent days.”

As well as receiving inadequate support, NGOs tasked with rescue efforts in the Mediterranean face lengthy legal battles and threats, the Council of Europe’s human rights commissioner warned earlier this year.

Sea-Watch, another German NGO, said a distress call warning of a fast-sinking dinghy days after the Bayesian tragedy was ignored. The vessel was carrying 43 people, including four children.

As the dinghy began to take on water, 12 people jumped overboard in an attempt to reduce weight, and were “struggling to stay afloat.”

The dinghy and its passengers were ignored by authorities for more than 24 hours despite regular distress calls.

It took an NGO vessel arriving “just in time” to rescue the passengers, Sea-Watch said, adding: “For the Italian and European authorities, there are Shipwrecks and then there are shipwrecks, one capitalised and the other lowercase, one immediately rescued and the other abandoned to its fate.”

Luca Casarini, a founder of the Mediterranea Saving Humans NGO, told The Guardian that it is “not wrong to intervene to save rich individuals aboard yachts or tourists.”

However, he added: “What is wrong is the inconsistency in applying these rescue strategies to save migrants in need.”


UK minister criticizes Israel’s proposed legislation against UNRWA efforts

UK minister criticizes Israel’s proposed legislation against UNRWA efforts
Updated 3 sec ago
Follow

UK minister criticizes Israel’s proposed legislation against UNRWA efforts

UK minister criticizes Israel’s proposed legislation against UNRWA efforts
  • Hamish Falconer highlighted the growing humanitarian crisis in Gaza, calling Israel’s potential decision “neither in Israel’s interest nor realistic”

LONDON: The UK’s Middle East minister has warned that Israel’s status as a democracy would be “deeply harmed” if the Knesset proceeded with a bill to cut all cooperation with the UN Relief and Works Agency, it was reported on Sunday.

Speaking at a London conference hosted by the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, Hamish Falconer highlighted the growing humanitarian crisis in Gaza, calling Israel’s potential decision “neither in Israel’s interest nor realistic.”

Falconer’s statements mark the strongest criticism from a Western official regarding the potential legislation, which is anticipated to reach a vote in the Knesset this week unless Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu intervenes.

The UK, along with six other European foreign ministries, have jointly urged Israel to drop the bill, emphasizing in a statement: “It is crucial that UNRWA and other UN organizations be fully able to deliver humanitarian aid and their assistance to those who need it most, fulfilling their mandates effectively.”

Falconer’s concern extended to the restrictions on aid entering Gaza, and he stressed the impact on civilian lives amid Israeli military operations, The Guardian reported.

“We are deeply concerned by legislation currently under consideration by the Israeli Knesset which would critically undermine UNRWA,” he said.

“Given the agency’s vital role in delivering aid and essential services at a time when more aid should be getting into Gaza, it is deeply harmful to Israel’s international reputation as a democratic country that its lawmakers are taking steps that would make the delivery of food, water, medicines, and healthcare more difficult.”

The UK minister, who recently visited the Egypt-Gaza border, described harrowing scenes, including “thousands of trucks waiting to cross … warehouses full of life-saving items — medical equipment, sleeping bags, and tarpaulin for the winter.”

He also noted that the level of aid “getting in is far too low,” with humanitarian convoys facing repeated attacks and significant blockages.

Falconer also raised concerns about Israel’s military approach in Gaza, calling for a balance between pursuing Hamas and protecting civilians.

“Hamas is a brutal terrorist organization, it hides behind Gazan civilians, but all parties must do everything possible to protect civilians and fully respect international humanitarian law,” he told the conference. “The Israeli government must take all necessary precautions to avoid civilian casualties, to ensure aid can flow into Gaza, and freely through all humanitarian land routes.”

Amid escalating tensions, Falconer advised “calmer heads to prevail,” while former UK Prime Minister Tony Blair, addressing the conference via video link, emphasized that “Hamas cannot be allowed to continue to govern Gaza.”

Blair advocated for the establishment of a new governance structure, adding: “Israel will need to pull back to allow the development of a different governance structure for Gaza that would then enable reconstruction to take place.”

Polls commissioned by the Tony Blair Institute, he shared, indicate that many residents favor international oversight and ties to the Palestinian Authority, with strong support for reform of the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank.


India warns social media after airline bomb threats

India warns social media after airline bomb threats
Updated 27 October 2024
Follow

India warns social media after airline bomb threats

India warns social media after airline bomb threats
  • Some threats led to planes being diverted to Canada and Germany, and fighter jets scrambled to escort aircraft above Britain and Singapore
  • The India government called the spread of the threats ‘dangerously unrestrained’ and warned social media platforms of ‘consequential action’

NEW DELHI: India has warned social media platforms of “consequential action” after hundreds of hoax bomb threats to Indian airlines this month triggered travel chaos and terror it said threatened national security.
Some threats led to planes being diverted to Canada and Germany, and fighter jets scrambled to escort aircraft in the skies above Britain and Singapore.
The government called the spread of the threats “dangerously unrestrained.”
It warned social media platforms of “consequential action as provided under any law” if they do not comply with the “prompt removal of misinformation.”
“The instances of malicious acts, in the form of hoax bomb threats to such airlines, lead to a potential threat to the public order and security of the state,” it said in a statement on Saturday.
“Such hoax bomb threats, while affecting a large number of citizens, also destabilizes the economic security of the country.”
At least 275 bomb threats were made since mid-October, all reported to have been false, according to the Press Trust of India (PTI) news agency. Other Indian media suggest it could be as high as nearly 400.
“The exemption from liability for any third party information... shall not apply if such intermediaries do not follow the due diligence obligations,” it added.
Civil aviation authorities have had to check every flight that has been threatened, many by messages posted on X, formerly Twitter.
The government warning did not mention any social media company by name, but cited an advisory notice from the information technology ministry.
“The scale of (the) spread of such hoax bomb threats has been observed to be dangerously unrestrained due to the availability of the option of ‘forwarding/re-sharing/re-posting/re-tweeting’ on the social media platforms,” the information ministry said.
It said companies must report any offenses “likely to threaten the unity, integrity, sovereignty, security or economic security” of the country, and cooperate swiftly with government agencies to aid investigations.
The government on Monday said it is discussing “legislative action” to overhaul aviation and aircraft security laws, and to make those who make such threats guilty of a serious, or “cognizable,” crime with longer potential sentences.
India, the world’s biggest democracy, regularly ranks among the top five countries globally for the number of requests made by a government to remove social media content.
Last year, an Indian court hit X with a $61,000 fine after the platform unsuccessfully challenged orders to remove tweets and accounts critical of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government.


Japan ruling party projected to miss majority in election

Japan ruling party projected to miss majority in election
Updated 27 October 2024
Follow

Japan ruling party projected to miss majority in election

Japan ruling party projected to miss majority in election
  • Voters in Japan have been rankled by rising prices and the fallout from a party slush fund scandal that helped sink previous premier Fumio Kishida

TOKYO: Japan’s scandal-hit ruling party fell short of a majority for the first time since 2009 in snap elections on Sunday, media projections showed, in a blow to new Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba.
Worse still, it was touch and go whether Ishiba’s conservative Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) could secure a parliamentary majority with its long-term coalition partner, the Komeito party.
“We are receiving severe judgment,” Ishiba told national broadcaster NHK late Sunday.
Voters “expressed their strong desire for the LDP to do some reflection and become a party that will act in line with the people’s will,” he said.
Former defense minister Ishiba, 67, called the election after being narrowly selected last month to lead the LDP, which has governed Japan for almost all of the past 70 years.
But voters in the world’s fourth-largest economy have been rankled by rising prices and the fallout from a party slush fund scandal that helped sink previous premier Fumio Kishida.
Footage from the LDP headquarters after the polls closed on Sunday showed gloomy faces as the projections based on exit polls said Ishiba’s justice and agriculture ministers were likely to lose their seats.
Ishiba, a self-confessed security policy geek who likes making model planes, had said his target in the election was for the coalition to win a majority.
Missing this goal would seriously undermine his position in the LDP and mean finding other coalition partners or leading a minority government.
“If we are unable to obtain a majority as a result of severe public judgment, we will ask as many people as possible to cooperate with us,” the LDP’s election chief Shinjiro Koizumi told reporters.
In Japan’s last general election in 2021, the LDP won a majority in its own right, with 259 seats in parliament’s powerful lower house. Komeito had 32.
On Sunday, national broadcaster NHK projected that the LDP would win between 153 and 219 seats — short of the 233 needed for a majority in the 465-seat parliament.
If confirmed by official results, the LDP losing its majority would be the worst result since it lost power 15 years ago before being brought back in a 2012 landslide by late former premier Shinzo Abe.
Together with Komeito, which is projected 21 to 35 seats, the coalition would hold between 174 and 254 seats, according to NHK.
Projections from the Asahi Shimbun and Yomiuri dailies suggested the coalition would lose its majority. The Asahi projected the LDP would win 185 seats and that the coalition would manage only 210.
Opinion polls before the election had suggested that in many districts, LDP candidates were neck-and-neck with those from the Constitutional Democratic Party (CDP), the second-biggest in parliament, led by popular former prime minister Yoshihiko Noda.
Projections on Sunday suggested that the CDP had made considerable gains, with NHK indicating it could win between 128 and 191 seats — up from 96.
“The LDP’s politics is all about quickly implementing policies for those who give them loads of cash,” 67-year-old Noda told his supporters on Saturday.
Noda said on Sunday night he would hold “sincere talks with various parties.”
“Our basic philosophy is that the LDP-Komeito administration cannot continue,” Noda told Fuji-TV.
Ishiba has pledged to revitalize depressed rural regions and to address the “quiet emergency” of Japan’s falling population through family-friendly measures such as flexible working hours.
But he has rowed back his position on issues including allowing married couples to take separate surnames. He also named only two women as ministers in his cabinet.
He has backed the creation of a regional military alliance along the lines of NATO to counter China, although he has cautioned it would “not happen overnight.”
Noda’s stance “is sort of similar to the LDP’s. He is basically a conservative,” Masato Kamikubo, a political scientist at Ritsumeikan University, told AFP before the election.
“The CDP or Noda can be an alternative to the LDP. Many voters think so.”


British lawmakers accuse Starmer of ‘colonial mindset’ in slavery reparations debate

British lawmakers accuse Starmer of ‘colonial mindset’ in slavery reparations debate
Updated 27 October 2024
Follow

British lawmakers accuse Starmer of ‘colonial mindset’ in slavery reparations debate

British lawmakers accuse Starmer of ‘colonial mindset’ in slavery reparations debate
  • Ahead of the Commonwealth heads of government summit in Samoa, where Caribbean and African nations wished to discuss the topic, Starmer said the issue was not on the agenda

LONDON: Some British Labour lawmakers on Sunday accused Prime Minister Keir Starmer of having a “colonial mindset” and trying to silence nations pushing for discussions on reparations for transatlantic slavery at this month’s Commonwealth summit in Samoa.
Britain has so far rejected calls for reparations but some campaigners hoped Starmer’s new Labour government would be more open to it.
However, ahead of the Commonwealth heads of government summit in Samoa, where Caribbean and African nations wished to discuss the topic, Starmer said the issue was not on the agenda and that he would like to “look forward” rather than have “very long, endless discussions about reparations on the past.”
“(It) is very insulting (to) tell people of African descent to forget and move forward,” said Labour lawmaker Bell Ribeiro-Addy at a cross-party reparations conference in London.
At the end the Samoa summit, leaders of the 56-nation club headed by Britain’s King Charles agreed to include in their final communique that the time had come for a discussion on reparations.
“I’m very proud those nations refused to be silenced,” Ribeiro-Addy said.
Another Labour lawmaker, Clive Lewis, said it was surprising Starmer thought he could take a “colonial mindset” to the summit and “dictate what could and could not be discussed.”
At a news conference in Samoa on Saturday, Starmer said slavery was “abhorrent” and that the discussions agreed to in the communique would not be “about money.”
A Downing Street spokesperson had no further comment on the remarks by Labour lawmakers on Sunday.
Proponents of reparations say slavery’s legacy has caused persistent racial inequalities while opponents say countries shouldn’t be held responsible for historical wrongs.
The lawmakers said that reparations could include a formal apology, debt cancelation, the return of artefacts or changing the school curriculum, not just financial payments.
Diane Abbott, Britain’s first Black woman lawmaker, said Labour previously had plans to establish a national reparations commission but Starmer “seems to have forgotten that.”
“Reparations isn’t about the past, it is about the here and now,” she said.


Muslim and Arab American leaders in Michigan endorse Trump

Muslim and Arab American leaders in Michigan endorse Trump
Updated 27 October 2024
Follow

Muslim and Arab American leaders in Michigan endorse Trump

Muslim and Arab American leaders in Michigan endorse Trump
  • Endorsement of Trump by Muslim and Arab communities would be a notable shift by Michigan’s Muslim community

DUBAI: Prominent Muslim leaders were invited by former US President Donald Trump on Saturday during a campaign rally in Michigan to announce their support for the Republican candidate.

Trump was joined onstage by what his campaign described as “prominent leaders of Michigan’s Muslim community” to encourage Muslim and Arab American to endorse him in the Nov. 5 presidential election.

The former president also said that he was banking on “overwhelming support” from these voters in the state, according to CNN.

“They could turn the election one way or the other,” Trump said of the Arab and Muslim communities, who are critical of US support for Israel in its war on Gaza.

On stage, the Muslim leaders cited Trump’s commitment to ending conflicts.

“We, as Muslims, stand with President Trump because he promises peace, not war,” Imam Belal Alzuhairi told the crowd. 

Alzuhairi described Trump as the “peace” candidate.

---------

CLICK HERE TO READ ARAB NEWS/YOUGOV POLL OF ARAB AMERICAN VOTERS

---------

“The bloodshed has to stop all over the world. And I think this man can make that happen.”

Trump said that Muslim and Arab voters in Michigan and across the country want a “stop to the endless wars and a return to peace in the Middle East.”

“That’s all they want,” he said.

The endorsement of Trump by Muslim and Arab communities would be a notable shift by Michigan’s Muslim community, who have traditionally aligned with the Democrats.