Climate change has unlikely victim in Pakistan: ancient Mohenjo Daro ruins

Special Climate change has unlikely victim in Pakistan: ancient Mohenjo Daro ruins
In this photograph taken on February 9, 2017, visitors walk through the UNESCO World Heritage archeological site of Mohenjo Daro some 425 kms north of the Pakistani city of Karachi. (AFP/file)
Short Url
Updated 13 June 2024
Follow

Climate change has unlikely victim in Pakistan: ancient Mohenjo Daro ruins

Climate change has unlikely victim in Pakistan: ancient Mohenjo Daro ruins
  • Archaeologists say heritage site under threat in Mohenjo Daro where temperatures rose as high as 52.2 C in May
  • The 2022 rains and floods also “severely damaged” the ruins, according to government and UNESCO officials 

LARKANA: As temperatures rose above 52.5 degrees Celsius (126 degrees Fahrenheit) in Pakistan’s southern province of Sindh amid a heat wave last month, a UNESCO world heritage site dating back to 2,500BC also felt the heat.

Archaeologists say ancient ruins are under threat in Mohenjo Daro, a town in Sindh that was once a major center of the Indus Valley Civilization, and where temperatures rose as high as 52.5 C (126 F) in May, the highest reading of the summer so far and approaching the town’s and country’s record highs of 53.5 C (128.3 F) and 54 C (129.2 F) respectively.

“Due to the prevailing heat wave, the ruins of Mohenjo Daro bricks are gradually melting,” Ali Hyder, an archaeological engineer with the Sindh Culture, Tourism & Antiquities Department who is posted in Mohenjo Daro, told Arab News.

“The temperature has been consistently rising to 50-51 degrees Celsius, which is unprecedented … This phenomenon is very dangerous for archaeological ruins in terms of salt crystallization and precipitation that may cause very severe damage to the archaeological ruins.”

Hyder said salt crystallization and precipitation resulting from unusually high temperatures were contracting the unbaked bricks used to build the ancient structures and could lead them to crumble. 

“You can see this wall is leaning and the main factor behind the leaning of the wall is extreme weather,” Hyder said as he pointed to a second century stupa built using sun-dried bricks and which had been propped up with metal rods. 

“It was also affected by extreme weather. We have provided it with a layer of sun-dried bricks to protect it from heat and rain … Due to rise in temperature, the evaporation and humidity available in the bricks, dehydration process starts, and the rate of deterioration rapidly increases. That is why we [have] provided support ensuring [protection] from further collapse … So that’s a very dangerous situation for Mohenjo Daro.”

Mohenjo Daro, the largest settlement of the Indus Valley civilization, is situated on the banks of the Indus River in Pakistan’s Larkana district, covering over 620 acres of land.

At its peak, the settlement rivaled contemporaneous cities in ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia, with a peak population of 40,000 before the site was abandoned in around 1,900 BCE. 

The city was designated a UNESCO world heritage site in 1980.

But human-driven climate change is now threatening its existence, Hyder said.

“In summer the salt available in the ruins contracts and in winter it expands in volume,” he said. “In the end come the [monsoon] rains that wash away different parts of the structural ruins.”

Pakistan ranks among the countries most vulnerable to climate change and has seen untimely downpours, deadly floods, heatwaves and droughts in recent years. A deadly heat wave that hit Pakistan’s largest city of Karachi, the capital of Sindh, claimed 120 lives in 2015.

In 2022, torrential monsoon rains triggered the most devastating floods in Pakistan’s history, killing around 1,700 people and affecting over 33 million. Millions of homes, tens of thousands of schools and thousands of kilometers of roads and railways are yet to be rebuilt.

“SEVERELY DAMAGED”

After the May heat wave, Pakistan witnessed another one in the first week of June and is expected to see a third in the last week of the month, according to Met officials. 

But heat is not the only threat to Mohenjo Daro, said Abdul Fatah Shaikh, the director general of the Archaeology and Antiquities Department in Sindh, explaining the damage to the ancient ruins from the 2022 rains and subsequent floods. 

“Mohenjo Daro is facing severe threats from extreme weather conditions, particularly rains and heat waves, which have impacted the upper artificial layer of mud slurry covering the original structure,” he told Arab News, saying the structures were so far “safe.”

“But it is still at risk, with a 10 percent impact already from extreme weather,” he added. “To provide extra protection, the upper artificial layer of mud slurry has been increased from 1 inch to 2.25 inches, in accordance with UNESCO guidelines.”

Given rising temperatures, an additional artificial layer of mud slurry was being considered for application from February next year, Shaikh explained. 

He said the damage from the 2022 rains and floods had been “conserved and preserved to 75 percent completion so far.”

“To combat these threats, the workforce has been increased from 30 laborers working before the 2022 rains arrived to 80 laborers in the post-2022 rains period to accelerate repairs and maintenance,” the official said. “The Mohenjo Daro site is vulnerable to brick decay, color change, and artificial layer decay due to the heat waves, making prompt action necessary to preserve this ancient archaeological site.”

Jawad Aziz, National Professional Officer (Culture) at UNESCO Islamabad, said Mohenjo Daro had been “severely damaged” during the 2022 monsoon season, including structural destruction like the collapse of walls and the development of cavities and holes in structures due to the loss of mud and bricks.

Heavy rainfall had also affected the drainage system, causing water to accumulate inside the ruins and leading to more damage to the structure.

“In response to the emergency situation, Aziz said, UNESCO mobilized the Emergency Assistance from the World Heritage Fund for the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage, established in 1977 under Article 15 of the World Heritage Convention.”

“UNESCO also mobilized international experts, who worked with the local team of Directorate of Antiquities and Archaeology, Sindh, and undertook the impact assessment, trained the local staff in disaster risk reduction and conservation techniques and undertook the immediate remedial measures as well as restoration work,” the UNESCO officer said.

“The remedial work focused on improving the drainage system, repaired the flooring, improved wall capping and slopes, underpinning, repaired the visitors path, adding shallow drain, restoration of several structures and cleaning the circular drain which was blocked with silt and wild growth at many spots.”


Pakistan Senate unanimously passes resolution condemning Israel’s bombardment of Gaza, Lebanon

Pakistan Senate unanimously passes resolution condemning Israel’s bombardment of Gaza, Lebanon
Updated 5 min 17 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan Senate unanimously passes resolution condemning Israel’s bombardment of Gaza, Lebanon

Pakistan Senate unanimously passes resolution condemning Israel’s bombardment of Gaza, Lebanon
  • Pakistan Peoples Party Senator Sherry Rehman moves resolution urging international community to protect Palestinian lives
  • Senate condemns Israel’s “exploitation of political vacuum” in Syria after the fall of Bashar Assad’s government in the country

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s upper house of parliament, the Senate, passed a unanimous resolution on Thursday condemning Israel’s bombardment of Gaza and Lebanon, urging the international community to protect Palestinian lives, state-run media reported. 

Israel’s military campaign in Gaza has killed more than 44,000 people and injured thousands more since the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks by Hamas in which Israel says 1,200 people were killed and 250 taken hostage. 

Israel’s 13-month military campaign has displaced an estimated 1.9 million Palestinians, many of them multiple times. Bombings, movement restrictions and evacuations ordered by Israel’s military block access to health care and keep aid workers from reaching people in need, with aid organizations and charities repeatedly warning of crisis-level hunger affecting nearly two million people.

Israel has also bombed Lebanon and traded missile strikes with Iran since its confrontation with Hamas, sparking fears of a wider conflict in the Middle East. The Jewish state’s military campaigns in the Middle East have triggered protests in Pakistan and other parts of the world for the past one year. 

“The Senate on Thursday passed a resolution unanimously condemning Israel’s bombardment extending to many countries,” the Associated Press of Pakistan (APP) reported. 

The resolution was moved by Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Senator Sherry Rehman on behalf of all political parties. 

As per the resolution, the Senate strongly condemned Israel’s blatant disregard for international law, particularly in its actions against Palestine and urged the Jewish state be held accountable.

The Senate also condemned Israel for its “exploitation of the political vacuum” in Syria as the government of Bashar Assad fell to opposition forces earlier this week. 

“This agenda now extends beyond Palestine to violations of the sovereignty of Syria and many other countries,” the resolution said. 

Calling for immediate accountability for Israel’s actions, the Senate also condemned the killing of United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) team members in the Middle East. 

Israel has killed 249 UNRWA staff members in its military campaigns carried out up till November this year, it added.

“Such attacks are a blatant violation of United Nations General Assembly Resolution 302; which mandates UNRWA’s role in providing critical humanitarian assistance to vulnerable populations,” the resolution said. 

Pakistan’s upper house of parliament also condemned the targeted killing of over 180 journalists during Israeli bombings in Gaza along with the destruction of critical infrastructure including hospitals, schools and even residential areas.

“The Senate reaffirms Pakistan’s unwavering support for the Palestinian cause, recognizing it as a moral, political, and legal obligation. Pakistan reiterates its consistent support for the two-state solution of the Palestinian issue, as enshrined in relevant Security Council and General Assembly resolutions,” the resolution stated. 

The Senate also urged the international community to take action to “protect Palestinian lives, hold Israel accountable for war crimes and ensure compliance with international humanitarian law.”

Since the beginning of Israel’s war on Gaza, Pakistan has repeatedly raised the issue at the UN, the Organization of Islamic Cooperation and other multilateral platforms, demanding international powers and bodies stop Israeli military actions in Gaza.

Pakistan has dispatched a total of 1,273 tons of relief items to the war-affected people of Gaza until Nov. 27, according to the National Disaster Management Authority.

The South Asian nation does not recognize nor have diplomatic relations with Israel and calls for an independent Palestinian state based on “internationally agreed parameters” and the pre-1967 borders with Al-Quds Al-Sharif as its capital.


Ex-Pakistan PM Khan’s party rejects reports of holding talks with government to ease tensions

Ex-Pakistan PM Khan’s party rejects reports of holding talks with government to ease tensions
Updated 12 December 2024
Follow

Ex-Pakistan PM Khan’s party rejects reports of holding talks with government to ease tensions

Ex-Pakistan PM Khan’s party rejects reports of holding talks with government to ease tensions
  • Reports of possible talks surfaced after Khan’s party leaders met ruling party member Ayaz Sadiq after his sister’s death
  • Khan announced earlier this month his party will launch civil disobedience campaign against government from Dec. 14

ISLAMABAD: Former prime minister Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party on Thursday refuted reports it had held talks with the government on easing political tensions in the country, stressing that the ex-premier would announce details of his anti-government civil disobedience movement on Dec. 14. 

Pakistani media reported that the government and PTI had agreed to ease political tensions in the country after PTI leaders Asad Qaiser and Salman Akram Raja met ruling party Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz’s (PML-N) member and National Assembly Speaker Ayaz Sadiq this week to offer condolences on his sister’s death. 

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif subsequently visited Sadiq’s residence, fueling speculation that the reported negotiations were discussed between Sadiq and the Pakistani premier. 

Reports of negotiations have surfaced after Khan earlier this month announced the PTI would launch a civil disobedience campaign from Dec. 14 if the government did not meet two of his demands. In a message to supporters on Dec. 5, the jailed Khan said he was setting up a five-member negotiations committee to hold talks with the federal government for the release of political prisoners, and also demanded judicial commissions to investigate protests on May 9 last year and Nov. 24 this year in which the government says his supporters partook in violence and caused vandalism. 

“There were no talks with the government when they [PTI leader] went for the condolence, nothing else was discussed or no political talk except the condolence happened,” Khan’s close aide and PTI spokesperson Sayed Zulfikar Bukhari told Arab News.

He said PTI was open to talks with everyone, however, he questioned whether the government had the authority or power to engage meaningfully with the opposition. 

Khan’s party alleges the Sharif-led coalition government came to power after rigging polls with the help of Pakistan’s all-powerful military. It frequently accuses the Sharif-led government of being a stooge of the military. 

Both deny the allegations and Pakistan’s military has repeatedly said it does not interfere in political matters. 

“As for talks with the government, we are happy to have talks with everybody but the question is does the government have any power or any authority, that will still remain to be seen,” Bukhari added. 

“Because at the moment they seem to have even less authority and power than us.”

Another PTI leader and an important member of its legal team, Muhammad Shoaib Shaheen, also endorsed Bukhari’s stance that there were no talks at any level between Khan’s party and the government. 

“Qaiser visited the speaker of the National Assembly only to offer condolences and any talks will happen only if the government shows seriousness toward the PTI’s demands,” Shaheen told Arab News.

Commenting on the PTI’s call for civil disobedience, Shaheen said Khan himself will announce the civil disobedience process and its details on or after Dec. 14. 

“If the government engages in talks with genuine intent, even then Khan will decide whether to postpone the movement,” Shaheen said. 

’ABANDON OLD WAYS’

Arab News reached out to government spokespersons, including Information Minister Ataullah Tarar and other members of Sharif’s cabinet for a comment. They did not respond till the filing of this report.

In an interview with local media on Wednesday night, Tarar dismissed the rumors of talks between the two sides as baseless, stating that there have been no formal discussions between the government and PTI.

Speaking on the floor of the Senate on Thursday, senior PML-N leader Irfan Siddiqui said the government is willing to engage in dialogue, but urged PTI to abandon its “old ways” and avoid creating undue pressure.

“Even today, we are ready for dialogue and will engage with an open heart, but do not hold a sword over our heads,” Siddiqui said. 

“Before any dialogue, PTI members must abandon their old ways,” he added.

Siddiqui said reconciliation was “a very good policy” and that if dialogue between the two sides did take place, solutions to political issues could be found.

“Peaceful protest is everyone’s right but this right is not unconditional,” he said.


UK aims to boost home-schooling safety after British-Pakistani girl’s murder

UK aims to boost home-schooling safety after British-Pakistani girl’s murder
Updated 20 sec ago
Follow

UK aims to boost home-schooling safety after British-Pakistani girl’s murder

UK aims to boost home-schooling safety after British-Pakistani girl’s murder
  • Ten-year-old Sara Sharif’s father, step-mother were convicted of murdering her this week
  • Months before death, her father had taken Sharif out of school to be taught at home

LONDON: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Thursday called for better safeguards for home-schooled children and said there were “questions that need to be answered” after the brutal murder of a 10-year-old girl.

Sara Sharif’s father and step-mother were convicted of murder on Wednesday in a trial that revealed gruesome details of the abuse inflicted on her, and the failure of child protection services to intervene despite warning signs.

Months before her death, her father Urfan Sharif had taken her out of school to be taught at home, after Sara’s teacher reported her bruises to child services.

At the time, child services had probed the incident but did not take any action.

Starmer said the “awful” case was “about making sure that (there are) protecting safeguards for children, particularly those being home-schooled.”

The Department for Education said it was “already taking action to make sure no child falls through the cracks” and “bringing in greater safeguards for children in home education.”

The government plans to “make sure that schools and teachers are involved in safeguarding decisions,” a Downing Street spokesperson said, adding that details would be included in upcoming legislation.

Parents will also need local authority consent for home-schooling at-risk children under the proposed changes, and a register of children who are not in school will be drawn up.

Sara was found dead in her home in August 2023, with extensive injuries including broken bones, burns and even bite marks after being subjected to years of abuse.

She had also been in and out of foster care after Sharif separated from her mother, Olga Sharif, to marry the step-mother Beinash Batool.

Despite previous allegations of abusive behavior against the father made by Olga, Sharif won custody of Sara in 2019, just four years before she was killed.

Children’s Commissioner Rachel de Souza said Sara’s death highlighted “profound weaknesses in our child protection system.”

De Souza said it was “madness” that an at-risk child could be taken out of school, calling for a ban on home-schooling of suspected abuse victims.

According to a child safeguarding report published on Thursday, 485 children in England died or were seriously harmed by abuse or neglect in the year to April 2024.

Urfan Sharif, Beinash Batool and Sara’s uncle Faisal Malik, who was cleared of murder but convicted of causing or allowing her death, are due to be sentenced on Tuesday.


Combatting smog, air pollution at center of discussions as Punjab chief minister visits China

Combatting smog, air pollution at center of discussions as Punjab chief minister visits China
Updated 12 December 2024
Follow

Combatting smog, air pollution at center of discussions as Punjab chief minister visits China

Combatting smog, air pollution at center of discussions as Punjab chief minister visits China
  • CM Maryam Nawaz Sharif on China visit from Dec. 8-15, meets China’s Ecology and Environment Minister 
  • Almost two million people from Pakistan fell sick when smog choked Punjab for over two weeks last month

ISLAMABAD: Combatting smog and air pollution has remained at the center of discussions this week as the chief minister of Pakistan’s most populous Punjab province, Maryam Nawaz Sharif, visits China on a week-long trip.

Smog had choked Pakistan’s eastern Punjab province for weeks last month, sickening nearly two million people and shrouding vast swathes of the province in a toxic haze. 

On Thursday, Lahore, the capital of Punjab, was listed as the world’s third most polluted city by Swiss air monitor IQAir, and its PM2.5 concentration, which comprises air particles that damage lungs, was 20.5 times the World Health Organization annual guideline value. Last month, the province had closed down schools and offices, banned outdoor activities and shortened timings for restaurants, shops and markets in a bid to control smog.

China has taken significant steps to combat its worsening air quality, declaring a “war on pollution” in 2015. Key measures include reducing coal consumption, increasing renewable energy capacity, and improving air quality monitoring systems. However, the Helsinki-based Center for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA) said last month in its annual assessment China’s emissions of carbon dioxide were on course to rise slightly this year, despite rapid progress on renewables and electric vehicles, putting a key 2025 climate target further out of reach.

“China is also a miracle in curbing pollution, smog mitigation, smog eradication and the steps that China has taken is not only an inspiration for us to learn from but also commend them,” CM Sharif said in televised comments during a meeting with Chinese Ecology and Environment Minister Huang Runqiu on Wednesday. 

“I am also completely and absolutely committed to making Punjab into a climate resilient Punjab.”

Briefing Chinese officials on Pakistan’s short-, medium- and long-term plans to combat air pollution, Sharif said:

“There is a complete plan that is in place which is environment conservation, biodiversity conservation, sustainable development and, most critical areas where we are working on daily basis, is air pollution, improving air quality standards and eradicating smog.”

Sharif said Pakistan would adopt the Chinese model of shifting industries out of cities to give people cleaner air to breathe.

Earlier this week, Sharif’s office said Punjab would develop an advanced air quality management system with the help of China and had set up a Beijing-Punjab Clean Air Joint Working Group.

“I suggest we form a working group where we can sit together on taking some tangible measures for smog mitigation, smog eradication and improving the air quality in Pakistan,” Sharif added. “We can exchange technologies, ideas, success stories and follow in China’s footsteps.”

She urged the working group to adopt a knowledge sharing policy regarding policy formulation, technology transfer, data, sharing, emission reduction strategies and e-transport.

On Thursday, the Punjab CM also invited a Chinese solar company to establish a manufacturing plan in Pakistan during her visit to the Jinko Solar Company in Shanghai, state broadcaster Radio Pakistan reported.

“The CM directed the concerned authorities of Punjab government to take necessary steps for setting up the solar manufacturing plant in the province,” the report said.


Pakistan’s second consignment of flood relief items for Malaysia arrives in Kuala Lumpur

Pakistan’s second consignment of flood relief items for Malaysia arrives in Kuala Lumpur
Updated 12 December 2024
Follow

Pakistan’s second consignment of flood relief items for Malaysia arrives in Kuala Lumpur

Pakistan’s second consignment of flood relief items for Malaysia arrives in Kuala Lumpur
  • Pakistan dispatched 40 tons of essential items such as lifejackets, tents, blankets and sleeping bags
  • Torrential rains and floods in Malaysia and Thailand this month killed at least 30, displaced thousands

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s second consignment of humanitarian assistance for the flood-hit people of Malaysia arrived in Kuala Lumpur on Thursday, the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) said. 

Pakistan dispatched a consignment of 40 tons of relief items from Islamabad on Wednesday night for the flood-hit people of Malaysia. Torrential rains and floods killed over 30 in Malaysia and Thailand and displaced tens of thousands in the two countries this month. 

“Upon arrival, the consignment was received by representatives of the Pakistan Embassy in Malaysia and the Malaysian National Disaster Management Agency (NADMA),” the NDMA said. 

It said the consignment featured essential supplies such as tents, blankets, quilts, mats, sleeping bags and life jackets.

The anti-disaster authority said it remains steadfast in its commitment to providing humanitarian assistance to Malaysia’s flood affectees. 

Pakistan sent its first shipment of 40 tons of relief items to Malaysia on Dec. 8.

Pakistan is one of the worst affected countries due to climate change impact, suffering cataclysmic floods in 2022 that killed over 1,700 people and destroyed critical infrastructure inflicting losses worth Rs33 billion.