In Pakistan’s ‘City of Saints,’ age-old feudal rivals fight it out in closely watched election contest

Special In Pakistan’s ‘City of Saints,’ age-old feudal rivals fight it out in closely watched election contest
Meher Bano Qureshi, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf-backed candidate, is pictured speaking to Arab News Pakistan in Multan, Pakistan, on February 3, 2024. (AN photo)
Short Url
Updated 05 February 2024
Follow

In Pakistan’s ‘City of Saints,’ age-old feudal rivals fight it out in closely watched election contest

In Pakistan’s ‘City of Saints,’ age-old feudal rivals fight it out in closely watched election contest
  • Qureshi and Gilani families of Multan have built political power on large landholdings, status as guardians of Sufi shrines
  • PTI-backed candidate Taimur Malik says people have rejected influential families and old-style patronage politics

MULTAN: Meher Bano Qureshi waved at the charged crowd of supporters chanting her name and showering her with rose petals as she climbed out of the imposing, black SUV in Multan in central Pakistan, where her family has built its political power on its status as guardians of one of the city’s many ornate, centuries-old Sufi shrines.

But as millions of Pakistanis go to the polls on Feb. 8, Qureshi is counting on something more temporal than prayers to tempt voters: the wild popularity of jailed former Prime Minister Imran Khan, whose Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party she is backed by. 

Her father Shah Mahmood Qureshi, Khan’s deputy in his party and foreign minister when the ousted PM ruled from 2018-2022, is the makhdoom, or guardian, of a prominent shrine and a large landowner to boot. Like dozens of other PTI leaders, Shah is barred from running in upcoming elections marred by widespread accusations of pre-poll rigging and interference by a military that Khan is widely believed to have fallen out with in the last months of his premiership. The army says it does not interfere in politics. 

“Within this constituency [NA-151] and within Pakistan, you can see that Imran Khan’s message is resonating with the people and they can see that this man walks the talk,” Qureshi, who is in her early forties, told Arab News in an interview, adding that a number of back to back jail sentences for Khan announced this month had only bolstered his popularity and those of the candidates supporting him. 

This month, her father was also awarded a 10-year jail sentence along with Khan in what has popularly come to be called the “cipher case,” in which the two are accused of leaking official secrets. Khan says all cases against him are politically motivated to keep him and his PTI out of elections. 

With its top leaders in prison, the PTI’s election contest has been further complicated by the election commission stripping the party of its unifying symbol of the bat, saying it had not conducted intra-party elections, a legal requirement. All candidates for the party now have to contest as independents, each with its own symbol. 

But the party and candidates like Qureshi believe the state-backed crackdown has only made them more popular.

“Today he [Khan] is in jail, my father [Shah] who was going to contest from here, he is also in jail,” Qureshi said. “They haven’t compromised, they have stood their ground, they have stood by the people of Pakistan and the people of Pakistan can see that and they appreciate it and therefore, they are standing with us.”

However, she admitted that the election race had been difficult due to “state highhandedness” which she described as being at an “unrelenting level.”

“It is a level that we haven’t seen before in any elections in Pakistan and this is a very unique election in terms of that,” Qureshi said. 

“Once we visit somewhere, even if it is a 50-person corner meeting, or a 15-person corner meeting, they are visited by police, they are given phone calls by local police and so, people are genuinely very fearful,” the candidate said, describing a pattern of intimidation she said the PTI and candidates backed by it were facing.




The picture taken on February 3, 2024, shows a vehicle decorated with the postures of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf party in Multan, Pakistan. (AN photo)

The caretaker government which is overseeing elections has repeatedly said all parties are being provided fair competition for the Feb. 8 polls while the military denies it interferes in election activities other than when asked by the election commission to provide security. 

“POLITICS OF DEVELOPMENT”

Up against Qureshi is the Gilani family led by ex-prime minister Yousaf Raza Gilani, currently a senator and a large landowner who commands the loyalty of thousands of devotees in the ancient city. Both clans are typical of the rural families that dominate politics in the main battleground province of Punjab, from where almost half the members of parliament will be elected.

In Multan’s NA-151, the largest constituency in Punjab in terms of land area, Qureshi’s is up against Ali Musa Gilani, the son of the older Gilani, backed by the Pakistan People’s Party.




The picture taken on February 3, 2024, shows people putting up banners of the Pakistan Peoples Party in Multan, Pakistan. (AN photo)

“The Qureshi family remained in power so many times, but they did nothing for the people of Multan and southern Punjab,” Ali told Arab News in an interview during campaigning activities this month.

“The Gilani family, whenever it came [to power], they did the politics of development, so, the people know who works for their welfare.” 

“We have done development projects worth billions of rupees in Multan and people know the Gilanis deliver on their promises,” the older Yousaf Raza Gilani told Arab News.

Out of six National Assembly constituencies in Multan, Meher Bano Qureshi and her brother Zain Qureshi are contesting from two separate seats. 

The older Gilani is contesting for a National Assembly seat, NA-148, with his son, Ali Haider Gilani, as the provincial assembly candidate. His two other sons, Ali Musa Gilani, and Abdul Qadir Gilani, are also contesting two separate National Assembly seats. All the Gilanis are candidates for the Pakistan Peoples Party.

Ali said he was confident the PPP would win from Multan and South Punjab and form the government in Punjab and at the center. 

“We will clean sweep Rahim Yar Khan, Muzaffargarh, Multan and I think we will win a seat from Lodhran,” Gilani said, naming multiple cities in southern Punjab. “And a seat from Bahawalpur and Bahawalnagar.”

“THE PEOPLE ARE FED UP”

In another Multan constituency, NA-148, the competition is between Yousaf Raza Gilani and Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) heavyweight, Malik Ahmed Hussain Deharr, and PTI-backed Barrister Taimur Malik.

Speaking to Arab News, Deharr said if voted into power, PML-N founder and three-time prime minister Nawaz Sharif would work with Pakistan’s powerful military on a “charter of economy” to steer the country from economic crisis. 

“I have high hopes that in the next five years, we will cover International Monetary Fund (IMF) loans and all that, and Pakistan will flourish,” Deharr told Arab News.

Malik on the other hand rejected politics dominated by influential families who have ruled for decades through patronage and the support of the army. 

“I really want to do politics of representation, politics of representing the wishes of the people, their grievances and of lawmaking in parliament which is a dire need for this country,” Malik told Arab News.

“The people are fed up with electing the same people, the people are fed up with going to their [feudal leaders’] deras [homes] and seeking their involvement in local issues,” he said. “People want educated [candidates] like myself who are also from the local area.”

Qureshi rebuffed Malik’s criticism about her feudal and political roots. 

“I am an educated woman,” she said. “I should be able to come forward once I fulfill the ideological criteria of a political party and be able to contribute to that party and to my country.”


Paris court sentences Pakistani who targeted Charlie Hebdo to 30 years jail

Paris court sentences Pakistani who targeted Charlie Hebdo to 30 years jail
Updated 32 sec ago
Follow

Paris court sentences Pakistani who targeted Charlie Hebdo to 30 years jail

Paris court sentences Pakistani who targeted Charlie Hebdo to 30 years jail
  • When he carried out attack, 29-year-old Zaheer Mahmood wrongly believed satirical newspaper was still based in the building
  • Newspaper had moved in the wake of an earlier attack, which killed 12 people including eight of the paper’s editorial staff

PARIS: A Paris court on Thursday sentenced a Pakistani man to 30 years in jail for attempting to murder two people outside the former offices of Charlie Hebdo in 2020 with a meat cleaver.
When he carried out the attack, 29-year-old Zaheer Mahmood wrongly believed the satirical newspaper was still based in the building, which was targeted by Islamists a decade ago for publishing cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.
The newspaper had in fact moved in the wake of the attack, which killed 12 people including eight of the paper’s editorial staff.
The killings in 2015 shocked France and triggered a fierce debate about freedom of expression and religion.
Originally from rural Pakistan, Mahmood arrived in France illegally in the summer of 2019.
The court had earlier heard how Mahmood was influenced by radical Pakistani preacher Khadim Hussain Rizvi, who had called for the beheading of blasphemers to “avenge the Prophet.”
Mahmood was convicted of attempted murder and terrorist conspiracy, and handed a ban from ever setting foot on French soil again.


Pakistan says three militants killed trying to infiltrating its border with Afghanistan

Pakistan says three militants killed trying to infiltrating its border with Afghanistan
Updated 23 January 2025
Follow

Pakistan says three militants killed trying to infiltrating its border with Afghanistan

Pakistan says three militants killed trying to infiltrating its border with Afghanistan
  • Islamabad frequently accuses Afghanistan of sheltering, supporting militant groups that launch cross-border attacks
  • Afghan officials deny state complicity, insisting Pakistan’s security issues are an internal matter of Islamabad

ISLAMABAD: Pakistani security forces have killed six militants attempting to enter the country through its border with Afghanistan in the southwestern Balochistan province, the Pakistan military said on Thursday.
Islamabad frequently accuses neighboring Afghanistan of sheltering and supporting militant groups that launch cross-border attacks. The Taliban government in Kabul says it does not allow Afghan soil to be used by militants, insisting that Pakistan’s security issues are an internal matter of Islamabad.
In the latest incident, the Pakistan army said security forces had picked up on the movement of a group of militants who were attempting to infiltrate the Pakistan-Afghanistan border on the night between Jan 22. and 23 in Balochistan’s Zhob District. Six militants were killed, it said, and a large quantity of weapons, ammunition and explosives was recovered.
“Pakistan has consistently been asking Interim Afghan Government to ensure effective border management on their side of the border,” the army said. “Interim Afghan Government is expected to fulfill its obligations and deny the use of Afghan soil by Khwarij for perpetuating acts of terrorism against Pakistan.”
The Pakistani Taliban, or the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), have frequently targeted Pakistani forces in the northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The group also has some presence in Balochistan, the site of a low-level insurgency for decades by separatists fighting for the province’s independence. 
On Jan. 19, Pakistani security forces killed five militants as they tried to infiltrate Pakistan’s border in Zhob district.


No talks with India on resumption of trade, Pakistan foreign office says

No talks with India on resumption of trade, Pakistan foreign office says
Updated 23 January 2025
Follow

No talks with India on resumption of trade, Pakistan foreign office says

No talks with India on resumption of trade, Pakistan foreign office says
  • In 2019, Indian PM Modi withdrew Indian-administered Kashmir’s autonomy to tighten grip over the territory
  • Move provoked outrage in Pakistan and the downgrading of diplomatic ties and suspension of bilateral trade

KARACHI: The Pakistani Foreign Office said on Thursday Islamabad and New Delhi were not holding talks to resume trade, suspended in 2019 when India revoked the special status of the part of Kashmir that it controls and split the region into two federally administered territories.
The disputed Himalayan region is claimed in full, though ruled in part by both India and Pakistan since their independence from Britain in 1947, with the nuclear-armed neighbors having fought two of their three wars over the territory.
In 2019, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi withdrew Indian-administered Kashmir’s autonomy in order to tighten his grip over the territory, provoking outrage in Pakistan and the downgrading of diplomatic ties and suspension of bilateral trade.
Speaking to reporters at the Indian embassy in Washington this week, Indian Foreign Minister Dr. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar said no talks on trade resumption had been held between his country and Pakistan.
“Pakistan decided to suspend bilateral trade in response to India’s illegal and unilateral actions of 5 August 2019 relating to ... Kashmir,” Shafqat Ali Khan, the spokesperson for Pakistan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told Arab News when asked to respond to the Indian minister’s comments. 
“High level engagement between Pakistan and India remains suspended at the moment. In that backdrop, both sides are not holding talks on resumption of trade.”
Khan said the volume of bilateral trade between Pakistan and India stood at $1.907 billion in the financial year 2018-19. He said India had in 2019 withdrawn the Most-Favored Nation status granted to Pakistan and imposed 200 percent duty on all Pakistani items, “posing a serious setback to Pakistan’s exports.”
Speaking on Wednesday, Jaishankar said it was Pakistan that had suspended trade.
“Their [Pakistan] government took a decision in 2019 not to conduct trade with India, that was from their side,” Jaishankar said. 
“Our concern regarding this issue from the beginning was that we should get MFN status. We used to give MFN status to Pakistan, they didn’t give [it] to us.”
For decades, the armies of India and Pakistan have faced off over the the Line of Control (LoC), a UN-monitored ceasefire line agreed in 1972, that divides the areas each administers.
The foes fought a 1999 battle along the LoC that some analysts described as an undeclared war. Their forces exchanged regular gunfire over the LoC until a truce in late 2003, which has largely held since.


PM launches World Bank’s $20 billion Country Partnership Framework for Pakistan

PM launches World Bank’s $20 billion Country Partnership Framework for Pakistan
Updated 23 January 2025
Follow

PM launches World Bank’s $20 billion Country Partnership Framework for Pakistan

PM launches World Bank’s $20 billion Country Partnership Framework for Pakistan
  • 10-year-plan will focus on development issues like impact of climate change and boosting private-sector growth
  • Last year, Pakistan secured $7 billion IMF loan deal though Sharif has vowed to reduce dependence on foreign loans

ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday launched the World Bank’s Country Partnership Framework (CPF) for Pakistan, a plan to focus $20 billion in loans to the cash-strapped nation over the coming decade on development issues like the impact of climate change and boosting private-sector growth.
Pakistan in 2023 nearly defaulted on the payment of foreign debts when the International Monetary Fund rescued it by agreeing to a $3 billion bailout to Pakistan. Last year, Islamabad secured a new $7 billion loan deal from the IMF. Since then, the country’s economy has started improving with weekly inflation coming down from 27 percent in 2023 to 1.8 percent earlier this month. Sharif has vowed to reduce dependence on foreign loans in the coming years.
The World Bank’s lending for Pakistan will start in 2026 and focus on six outcomes: improving education quality, tackling child stunting, boosting climate resilience, enhancing energy efficiency, fostering inclusive development and increasing private investment.
“Together, this partnership fosters a unified and focused vision for your county around six outcomes with clear, tangible and ambitious 10-year targets,” Martin Raiser, the World Bank vice president for South Asia, said in an address at the launch ceremony of the loan program. 

World Bank Vice President for South Asia Martin Raiser (right) presents a copy of booklet of World Bank’s Country Partnership Framework for Pakistan to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif during the launching ceremony in Islamabad on January 23, 2025. (Photo courtesy: PMO)

 “We hope that the CPF will serve as an anchor for this engagement to keep us on the right track. Partnerships will equally be critical. More resources will be needed to have the impact at the scale that we wish to achieve and this will require close collaboration with all the development partners.”
Speaking at the ceremony, PM Sharif said the CPF was a “vision to transform Pakistan’s economy, building climate resilient projects, alleviating poverty and unemployment and promoting digitization, agriculture and IT led initiatives.”
Separately, Raiser met Ahad Cheema, Pakistani minister for economic affairs, to discuss in detail the framework’s next steps and its implementation. 
“The two leaders also discussed the need to address key challenges in project implementation, such as land acquisition, project start-up delays, and ensuring compliance with social safeguards,” Cheema’s office said in a statement.
“Cheema stressed that effective coordination between the World Bank and other development partners, as well as streamlined approval processes, would be essential to overcoming these hurdles.”
Cheema also called on the World Bank to enhance Pakistan’s allocation of concessional resources, especially in support of climate change mitigation and foreign debt management.


Afghans in Pakistan awaiting US resettlement feel betrayal after Trump order

Afghans in Pakistan awaiting US resettlement feel betrayal after Trump order
Updated 23 January 2025
Follow

Afghans in Pakistan awaiting US resettlement feel betrayal after Trump order

Afghans in Pakistan awaiting US resettlement feel betrayal after Trump order
  • Nearly 1,660 Afghans cleared by US government to resettle are having flights canceled 
  • President Trump on inauguration day passed an order suspending US refugee programs

ISLAMABAD: A decision by President Donald Trump’s administration to halt visa processing for refugees has caused uncertainty and shock at an English school for Afghans in Islamabad who are awaiting resettlement in the United States.
Normally enthusiastic students were quiet or crying in class after the news broke on Tuesday, said Sayed Hasseb Ullah, a 20-year-old teacher whose application for resettlement in the US is in process.
Some feel betrayed, with many — including those who fled Taliban rule in Afghanistan — having already spent years in limbo.
“It was really a horrible moment for us. We have been waiting for almost three years and there is no hope anymore,” he told Reuters at the school in Pakistan’s capital.
The sudden delay has upended the plans of many Afghans in Pakistan and left them in despair after undergoing extensive vetting and making preparations for new lives in the US

Syed Hasseb Ullah, 20-year-old Afghan citizen and a teacher, who is in the process for resettlement in the US speaks during an interview with Reuters on the outskirts of Islamabad, Pakistan on January 22, 2025. (REUTERS)

In an intermediate language class, about half of which had US visa applications in process, a 16-year-old girl broke down in tears.
“I feel very bad from this news,” she said, unable to focus on her work — practicing a list of English phrases for giving formal presentations that was written on the class whiteboard.
She hopes to enroll in high school in the US after being barred from pursuing her education at school in Afghanistan.
The tutoring academy, which has roughly 300 students, is one of the few spaces available for studying for many Afghans waiting for US visas. They cannot legally work or formally study in Pakistan.
Shawn VanDiver, the founder of #AfghanEvac, the leading coalition of resettlement and veterans groups, said there were 10,000-15,000 Afghans in Pakistan waiting for special immigration visas or resettlement in the US as refugees.
Many have waited for years after being instructed when applying to travel to a third country for processing. For many the only option was Pakistan, which borders Afghanistan but, facing economic and security crises, began deporting tens of thousands of Afghans in 2023.
A spokesperson for Pakistan’s foreign ministry did not immediately respond to request for comment on the US announcement.
FLIGHTS CANCELLED?
Nearly 1,660 Afghans cleared by the US government to resettle in the US, including family members of active-duty US military personnel, are having their flights canceled under the order suspending US refugee programs, Reuters reported on Monday.
One of Hasseb Ullah’s students, Fatima, has no idea whether an official email she received on Jan. 14 — and seen by Reuters — seeking documents to proceed with her family’s travel arrangements for the US is still valid.
The 57-year-old women’s rights and development advocate who worked for years for US-funded organizations in central Daikundi province began learning English a few months ago.
She said she had previously never imagined leaving Afghanistan and that she and many others had trusted the US — which spent two decades leading foreign forces in Afghanistan, backing the now-collapsed government and spending billions of dollars on human rights and development programs.
“You supported us at that time and raised us up so we worked with you and after that you invited us to a third country (for visa processing) and now you are doing something like this,” she said.
In addition to concerns about her own safety following her advocacy work, Fatima is particularly worried about her 15-year-old daughter. She hopes she can enroll in school in the US after years out of high school, and that her 22-year-old daughter can complete her engineering degree.
Many students and teachers said they had contacted UN agencies and the US embassy this week and were sharing any information they could find on the Internet in WhatsApp groups. But there were few clear answers.
The US embassy and State Department did not immediately provide comment in request to a question from Reuters on whether the new order would affect Afghans waiting in Pakistan for visas.
“We have been living here for three years with a hope of going to America to be safe but now when President Donald Trump came ... and told us we will not process these case or maybe we will delay it, indeed you feel betrayed,” Hasseb Ullah said.
“I just wanted to tell them respectfully that we have helped you and now we expect help back from you.”