How digital archives are preserving Palestinian history amid Israel’s bombardment of Gaza

Special How digital archives are preserving Palestinian history amid Israel’s bombardment of Gaza
A Palestinian civil defense worker checks documents reduced to ashes, inside the archives department of the Gaza municipality building in Gaza City. (Photos on page: Supplied by Zachary Foster & AFP)
Short Url
Updated 09 January 2024
Follow

How digital archives are preserving Palestinian history amid Israel’s bombardment of Gaza

How digital archives are preserving Palestinian history amid Israel’s bombardment of Gaza
  • As Israeli bombing puts historical records to the torch, online platforms may become the last repository of Gaza’s heritage
  • US-based Palestine Nexus features maps, documents, and rare publications drawn from archives across the Middle East

LONDON: Israel’s bombardment of the Gaza Strip has resulted in the damage and destruction of precious records and archives, placing the preservation of Palestinian heritage and identity in jeopardy, scholars have warned.

Keen to preserve items and documents pertaining to the history of Palestine, a digital platform, Palestine Nexus, launched in 2020, has redoubled its efforts to gather and protect treasures drawn from archives across the Middle East.

“With the number of stories of people that are being literally wiped off the face of the earth, this is like a tiny, tiny contribution, but it just feels like an obligation,” Zachary Foster, the founder and owner of Palestine Nexus, told Arab News.

“I believe in preserving Palestinian memory in history … and I’m proud to contribute to that.”




Documents reduced to ashes are scattered inside the archives department of the Gaza municipality building. (AFP/File)

Israel mounted its military campaign in Gaza in retaliation for the unprecedented Oct. 7 attack on southern Israel by the Palestinian militant group Hamas, which saw 1,200 people killed, most of them civilians, with 240 taken hostage.

In the months since the outbreak of fighting, more than 22,700 people have been killed in Gaza by Israel’s bombardment, according to the Hamas-run health ministry, while almost 2 million have been displaced.

Civilian infrastructure has been damaged or destroyed and only limited humanitarian aid has been permitted to enter the embattled enclave, leaving the population vulnerable to hunger and disease.

Amid the unfolding humanitarian catastrophe, it has been easy to overlook the harm the conflict has caused to cultural, educational and heritage sites and the historical artifacts held therein. This has seen the erasure of significant elements of Palestinian history and identity.

In late November, Gaza’s Central Archives, which contained thousands of historical documents dating back more than 150 years, was destroyed.

In an interview with Turkiye’s Anadolu news agency, Yahya Al-Sarraj, head of Gaza’s municipality, described the destruction of the archives as a deliberate attempt to “erase a large part of our Palestinian memory.”

Other sites of cultural significance damaged or destroyed in recent weeks include the Mavi Marmara Martyrs Memorial in Gaza Port, the memorial of the late journalist Shireen Abu Akleh in the West Bank’s Jenin refugee camp, and the memorial of the late President Yasser Arafat in Tulkarm, also in the West Bank.

Gaza’s largest public library has also been destroyed. In response, municipal authorities called on UNESCO to “intervene and protect cultural centers and condemn the occupation’s targeting of these humanitarian facilities protected under international humanitarian law.”

Israel insists its armed forces are only targeting Hamas fighters, commanders, weapons caches and tunnel networks — not civilians and civilian infrastructure or sites of cultural, religious or historical significance.

Even before the conflict in Gaza began, Omar Suleiman, an American-Muslim scholar, had warned of a systematic erasure of the concept of Palestine — from maps, academic works, and the public discourse itself.

“It’s not just the Palestinian people or the name of the country that’s disappearing, but the word Palestine itself,” Suleiman said in a recent op-ed for Al Jazeera. “Palestine is being deliberately erased from our consciousness and discourse, during war and even in peace.”

As the conflict persists in Gaza, scholars will increasingly have to rely on digital archives to access primary source materials because hard copies are damaged or destroyed. As a result, platforms such as Palestine Nexus will become more vital than ever.

“I became interested in Palestinian history and identity because I was raised with all of these myths about how there was no such thing as Palestinian people,” said Foster, a US citizen of Jewish heritage. “I wanted to know if all those stories that I heard were true or not.”




A worker walks toward the archives department of the Gaza municipality building in Gaza City during Israel-Hamas war. (AFP/File)

Foster’s academic quest to discover the origins of Palestinian identity led him to collect a mesmerizing array of maps of Palestine from the 19th century. These beautifully crafted and incredibly rare documents became the cornerstone of Palestine Nexus.

“It was my argument that maps of Palestine played a key role in explaining why it is that people began to identify as Palestinian and so I tried to find every map of Palestine from the 19th century that I can find,” he said.

“And at some point, I realized I had a lot more than just maps.”

As Foster delved deeper, his project evolved from a personal interest in Palestinian history and identity into a mission to make rare historical documents accessible to a global audience. He expanded his collection beyond maps to encompass digital copies of diaries, manuscripts, newspapers, and archival materials.

Soon, Palestine Nexus had transformed into a comprehensive repository, not limited to Palestine but extending its reach to the broader Middle East.

The curated repository, now boasting more than 40,000 objects, includes identification papers, official records, letters, diaries, manuscripts, maps, photographs, films, and audio recordings, and even the first dual-language geography book chronicling the history of Palestine in Greek and Arabic, published in 1904.

Additionally, it houses the first “History of Gaza” penned and published in Arabic in the 20th century by ‘Arif Al-‘Arif and hundreds of documents covering the periods of Ottoman and British rule.

It also features the “Palestinian Arab Index, 1946,” a book that constitutes one of the most comprehensive and contemporary indices of books published in Palestine or by Palestinian Arabs in the first half of the 20th century.

After years of treasure hunting across the region, which took him to Egypt, Turkiye, and Palestine, Foster’s visit to Gaza unearthed a unique collection spanning the social, political, and economic history of Palestine from the 1910s to the 1980s.

Saleem Elrayes, an antiques dealer from Gaza City, had compiled a collection that chronicled the social history of Gaza during the 1948 war, documents related to his family business importing coal from Sudan in the 1910s, and a diverse array of maps depicting events in the Gulf, including Saddam Hussein’s invasion of Kuwait in 1990.

The chronicle, named the Gaza Collection, was partially acquired by Foster, who transported it to the US and digitized the materials so that it could be accessed by scholars for free on Palestine Nexus.

“I visited Gaza twice,” said Foster. “The first time I bought maybe 400 (to) 500 documents, and the second time I went back, I bought another 300 (to) 400 documents.” However, his meeting with Elrayes unlocked a gold mine of previously unseen material.




Documents reduced to ashes are scattered inside the archives department of the Gaza municipality building. (AFP/File)

“He has five, 10 times as many documents as I purchased,” said Foster, who is mesmerized by Gaza’s unexpected archival richness, considering its challenging circumstances over the past 16 years of Hamas rule and Israeli embargo.

However, the chances of a return visit to Gaza in the near future appear slim. Elrayes, the custodian of this unique collection, was forced to abandon his home in Gaza City following heavy Israeli bombardment.

It is not yet known whether his antiques shop is still standing or has been “blown to pieces.” The uncertainty surrounding the fate of this physical archive lends even greater significance to digital preservation efforts.

Reflecting on his platform’s importance, Foster underscored how the documents in the Palestine Nexus archive are a testament to the rich history, culture, and memory of the Palestinian people, countering a narrative that often seeks to erase or downplay their identity.

“The Gaza municipal archives were destroyed. Saleem’s archive may well have been destroyed. The entire 60 (to) 75 percent of the housing stock is destroyed. Everything has been destroyed. And yet, people’s history exists and it will be preserved,” said Foster.

With nearly 200 access requests and more than 500 expressions of interest, Foster says he is curious to know who is accessing the collection, mindful of the growing impact of — and public engagement with — the project.

He said the interest in this “obscure collection” is a remarkable achievement, signifying a genuine concern for the fate of these historical documents and the stories that they contain.

Looking ahead, Foster says he hopes Palestine Nexus will inspire other archival initiatives, fostering a culture of open access to historical documents, crucial for Palestinians facing barriers to physical access and ensuring preservation in the face of potential destruction.


Israeli foreign minister says ICC “lost all legitimacy” with Netanyahu, Gallant ruling

Israeli foreign minister says ICC “lost all legitimacy” with Netanyahu, Gallant ruling
Updated 12 sec ago
Follow

Israeli foreign minister says ICC “lost all legitimacy” with Netanyahu, Gallant ruling

Israeli foreign minister says ICC “lost all legitimacy” with Netanyahu, Gallant ruling
“A dark moment for the International Criminal Court,” Saar said on X

JERUSALEM: The International Criminal Court has “lost all legitimacy” after issuing arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former defense chief Yoav Gallant, Israel’s Foreign Minister Gideon Saar said on Thursday.
“A dark moment for the International Criminal Court,” Saar said on X, adding that it had issued “absurd orders without authority.”
Meanwhile, Netanyahu said he ‘rejects with disgust’ the international court arrest warrant.

Displaced by war, cancer patients in Lebanon struggle for survival

Displaced by war, cancer patients in Lebanon struggle for survival
Updated 43 min 21 sec ago
Follow

Displaced by war, cancer patients in Lebanon struggle for survival

Displaced by war, cancer patients in Lebanon struggle for survival

BEIRUT: Lebanese small business owner Ahmad Fahess thought nothing could be more devastating than his cancer diagnosis until suddenly, while he was at work one day, Israeli airstrikes started targeting his town of Nabatieh in south Lebanon.
When he saw the tangled mess around him, he knew he had to grab his family and flee.
“We want to go back to our homes, to our work,” he said, breaking into tears as he received cancer treatment at the American University of Beirut’s Medical Center (AUBMC), his sister sitting next to his bed.
Israel launched a broad attack on southern Lebanon in September, almost a year after Iran-backed Hezbollah militants there stepped up their rocket fire on northern Israel as Israeli forces fought Hamas gunmen who had attacked Israel from Gaza.
Washington is trying to broker a ceasefire but Israel says it must be able to continue defending itself. It says Hezbollah uses civilians as human shields, something the militants deny.
A father of two teenagers who owned four welding shops in Nabatieh, Fahess is now not only unsure when he will be able to go home, but also how long he will be able to access treatment for the rare cancer, sarcoma, which affects the connective tissue in his left arm.
“I used to come three days to Beirut for treatment and go back home,” he said. “Now with the war, we were displaced, and the treatment struggle started.”
Thousands of cancer patients are among more than a million people who have fled their homes.
“It all happened very quickly. We were at work when the shelling started; we were surprised by it,” he said. He fled with his family to Antelias in Mount Lebanon with only $4,500 that quickly dwindled.
Fahess now depends on the hospital’s Cancer Support Fund, a charity initiative launched in 2018 to assist cancer patients and now also giving extra support to displaced individuals.
“The treatment is costly; if the hospital didn’t help me, I couldn’t have afforded it,” he said.
But he is worried about funding drying up. “If we have to pay and we’re back at our homes, it would be fine, but if we are still displaced, it’ll be impossible,” he said.
Lebanon’s health ministry said more than 2,500 displaced cancer patients have been forced to find new treatment centers, as at least eight hospitals in southern Lebanon and Beirut’s southern suburbs were out of action due to Israeli shelling.
Cancer was already expensive to treat under Lebanon’s health care system, which in recent years has been battered further by economic crisis.
It is now under severe strain, said Ali Taher, the director of the Naef K. Basile Cancer Institute at AUBMC, adding that treating displaced patients has brought new complications, including finding their missing medical records and doctors.
“It’s also difficult to get cancer screening ahead of time because it’s no longer a priority for people,” Taher said.
Ghazaleh Naddaf, 67, was displaced from the southern village of Debel. Now living with her brother in Beirut, the former pharmacist assistant lost her job and has been unable to afford her therapy for multiple myeloma for two months.
“I am skipping treatment and medication,” she said. “I used to come twice a week for treatment, paying over $1,000. I can’t afford it anymore,” adding that she also needs a bone marrow transplant costing $50,000, an expense far beyond her reach.
“It’s war, and there is no safety, and I still need to go through the treatment to get on with my life,” she said.
Hala Dahdah Abou Jaber, co-founder of the Cancer Support Fund, said displaced cancer patients have to choose between basic necessities and life-threatening therapies and many can no longer co-pay for their treatment.
“Cancer doesn’t wait. Cancer is not a disease that gives you time; it’s harsh,” she said.


Iran president visits Sistan-Baluchistan after deadly attack

Iran president visits Sistan-Baluchistan after deadly attack
Updated 50 min 44 sec ago
Follow

Iran president visits Sistan-Baluchistan after deadly attack

Iran president visits Sistan-Baluchistan after deadly attack

TEHRAN: Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian arrived in the restive southeast of Iran on Thursday for a visit to Sistan-Baluchistan province, state media reported, nearly a month after one of the deadliest ever attacks in the region.
Sistan-Baluchistan, located some 1,200 kilometers (745 miles) from the capital Tehran, shares a long border with Pakistan and Afghanistan and has experienced recurring clashes between Iranian security forces and rebels from the Baluch minority, radical Sunni groups and drug traffickers.
On October 26, ten police officers were killed in what the authorities described as a “terrorist” attack.
Pezeshkian arrived at the airport in the regional capital Zahedan for a one-day visit during which he was set to meet the families of the dead police officers, state television reported.
Since the October 26 attack, Iranian forces have launched a vast counterterrorism operation in Sistan-Baluchistan that is ongoing, during which at least 26 militants have been killed and around fifty people arrested, according to the authorities.
The Sunni jihadist group Jaish Al-Adl — Army of Justice in Arabic — based in Pakistan and active in southeastern Iran, claimed responsibility for the attack in a message on Telegram.
The Iranian president is also scheduled to visit the Chabahar Free Trade-Industrial Zone, a major project aimed at developing southern Iran.
Chabahar Port, which bypasses the heavy traffic of the Strait of Hormuz, is aimed at attracting businesses from nearby Pakistan, India, the Gulf and China among others.
Chabahar, located on the edge of the Indian Ocean, was exempted by Washington from the economic sanctions it unilaterally reimposed after withdrawing from a landmark nuclear agreement.
Sistan-Baluchistan, one of the most impoverished provinces in the country, is home to a large number of the Baluch minority, an ethnic group spread between Iran, Pakistan and Afghanistan which practices Sunni Islam in contrast to the country’s predominantly Shiite population.


International Criminal Court issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant

International Criminal Court issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant
Updated 21 November 2024
Follow

International Criminal Court issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant

International Criminal Court issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant
  • The decision turns Netanyahu and the others into internationally wanted suspects and is likely to further isolate them and complicate efforts to negotiate a ceasefire to end the 13-month conflict

THE HAGUE: The International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants on Thursday for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, his former defense minister and Hamas officials, accusing them of war crimes and crimes against humanity over the war in Gaza and the October 2023 attacks that triggered Israel’s offensive in the Palestinian territory.
The decision turns Netanyahu and the others into internationally wanted suspects and is likely to further isolate them and complicate efforts to negotiate a ceasefire to end the 13-month conflict. But its practical implications could be limited since Israel and its major ally, the United States, are not members of the court and several of the Hamas officials have been subsequently killed in the conflict.
Netanyahu and other Israeli leaders have condemned ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan’s request for warrants as disgraceful and antisemitic. US President Joe Biden also blasted the prosecutor and expressed support for Israel’s right to defend itself against Hamas. Hamas also slammed the request.
“The Chamber considered that there are reasonable grounds to believe that both individuals intentionally and knowingly deprived the civilian population in Gaza of objects indispensable to their survival, including food, water, and medicine and medical supplies, as well as fuel and electricity,” the three-judge panel wrote in its unanimous decision to issue warrants for Netanyahu and his former defense minister, Yoav Gallant.
The Israeli Foreign Ministry said in September that it had submitted two legal briefs challenging the ICC’s jurisdiction and arguing that the court did not provide Israel the opportunity to investigate the allegations itself before requesting the warrants.
“No other democracy with an independent and respected legal system like that which exists in Israel has been treated in this prejudicial manner by the Prosecutor,” Foreign Ministry spokesperson Oren Marmorstein wrote on X. He said Israel remained “steadfast in its commitment to the rule of law and justice” and would continue to protect its citizens against militancy.
The ICC is a court of last resort that only prosecutes cases when domestic law enforcement authorities cannot or will not investigate. Israel is not a member state of the court. The country has struggled to investigate itself in the past, rights groups say.
Despite the warrants, none of the suspects is likely to face judges in The Hague any time soon. The court itself has no police to enforce warrants, instead relying on cooperation from its member states.


Israel, Hezbollah trade deadly blows despite ceasefire talks

Israel, Hezbollah trade deadly blows despite ceasefire talks
Updated 46 min 43 sec ago
Follow

Israel, Hezbollah trade deadly blows despite ceasefire talks

Israel, Hezbollah trade deadly blows despite ceasefire talks
  • In Israel, a 30-year-old man was killed when shrapnel from a rocket struck a playground in the northern town of Nahariya
  • In southern Lebanon, an Israeli airstrike killed three people in the village of Chaaitiyeh

JERUSALEM/BEIRUT: Israel and Lebanon’s Hezbollah traded deadly blows on Thursday as their war raged on despite signs of progress in US ceasefire efforts, with airstrikes pounding Beirut’s southern suburbs and rockets flying into northern Israel.
US mediator Amos Hochstein was in Israel for talks with Israeli officials to try to secure a ceasefire which he said was “within our grasp” during a visit to Beirut earlier this week.
The diplomacy marks the most serious attempt yet to end the conflict between Israel and the heavily armed, Iran-backed Hezbollah, part of the regional spillover of the Gaza war that erupted more than a year ago.
In southern Lebanon, an Israeli airstrike killed three people in the village of Chaaitiyeh, some 10 km (6 miles), from the border, the Lebanese health ministry said.
In Israel, a 30-year-old man was killed when shrapnel from a rocket struck a playground in the northern town of Nahariya, Israel’s MDA medical service said.
“The Israeli government is not safeguarding my security, my residents or the residents of the north (of Israel). It is not possible to live in such a situation like this,” Nahariya Mayor Ronen Marelly told public broadcaster Kansas
The Israeli military said about 10 rockets were launched from Lebanon toward Nahariya. “Most of the projectiles were intercepted and fallen projectiles were identified,” the military said in a statement.
Channel 12 said three rockets hit the coastal town.
Hezbollah’s Al-Manar television station, citing its correspondent, confirmed rocket fire toward Nahariya and the surrounding area.
Airstrikes on Beirut’s Hezbollah-controlled southern-suburbs shook the capital, sending up thick clouds of debris.
The Israeli military issued a statement on X ahead of strikes warning residents they were near Hezbollah targets against which it would soon take action. Residents have largely fled the area since Israel went on the offensive in September.
White House envoy Hochstein left for Israel after declaring progress during two days of talks in Lebanon with officials including Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri, endorsed to negotiate by the Iran-backed Hezbollah. Speaking before he left Beirut, Hochstein said he was going to Israel to try to close an agreement if possible.
The diplomacy aims to end a conflict that has inflicted massive devastation in Lebanon since Israel began its offensive, mounting airstrikes across wide parts of the country and sending in troops.
Footage broadcast by Al Jazeera showed thick smoke rising from the town of Khiyam in southern Lebanon, some 6 km (4 miles) from the border, a focal point of ground battles between Hezbollah fighters and Israeli troops.
Israel says its aim is to secure the return home of tens of thousands of people evacuated from its north due to rocket attacks by Hezbollah, which opened fire in support of Hamas at the start of the Gaza war in October 2023.
Hezbollah, which has suffered major blows since Israel began its offensive in September, has kept up rocket fire into Israel, attacking Tel Aviv this week. Its fighters are battling Israeli troops on the ground in the south.
The casualty toll since Oct., 2023 stands at 3,558 people killed in Lebanon, the Lebanese health ministry says, most of them killed during the Israeli offensive since September. The figures do not distinguish between combatants and civilians. The ministry said 14 fatalities were reported on Tuesday.
Hezbollah strikes have killed more than 100 people in northern Israel and the Israeli-occupied Golan Heights. They include more than 70 soldiers killed in strikes in northern Israel and the Golan Heights and in combat in southern Lebanon, according to Israel.