Imran Khan’s development promises may face setback if economy keeps worsening, warn economists

KARACHI: As Pakistan is expected to use the International Monetary Fund’s loan facility to steer the country out of prevailing economic crisis, economists believe the country will have to bear the brunt of being on the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) gray list.
Imran Khan, the next prime minister of Pakistan in line, promises to work on human development in the country but his party faces tough economic challenges and is left only with the option to move to the IMF.
Pakistan was put on list of “Jurisdictions with strategic deficiencies,” known as the gray list, by the money laundering and terrorism-financing watchdog FATF. It was listed on June 29, 2018. The country has been on the list twice, in 2008 and 2012.
“Pakistan has been put on gray list of FATF, which means the IMF loan will be extended at higher interest rates and the burden will again be shifted on to the vulnerable and tax-paying class,” Dr. Ayub Mehar, research economist at Asian Development Bank Institute, told Arab News.
There is no question of the IMF denying loans to Pakistan by IMF because it is responsible for the fund to facilitate the member country, Mehar said. Pakistan can avail under special drawing rights up to $2.8 billion from the IMF.
The IMF program’s condition may include expenditure cuts as part of government austerity, which in turn will affect the economically vulnerable class in Pakistani society. “The IMF comes with its own assessment of the country but it largely depends on the extent to which the government can effectively negotiate terms with the fund,”, Dr. Asad Sayeed, research economist at the Institute of Development and Economic Alternatives, told Arab News.
As part of its expenditure cut, the government is likely to withdraw subsidies being given to the poor segment. “Whenever the expenditure cut is talked about, it is always viewed by which segment is going to bear the brunt. It will depend how the government is going to protect the interest of the poor, middle-class segments,” Dr. Sayeed noted.
The economists believe Khan’s government will have to confront a huge current account deficit, caused by trade and fiscal deficits, and the instability of the national currency which has been devalued for the fourth time since December 2017. “The IMF will call for further devaluation of the Pak rupee and expenditure cuts which means the country will have to compromise on the its development spending,” Muzzamil Aslam, senior economist and CEO of EFG-Hermes Pakistan, told Arab News.
The rising imports have increased the current account deficit of Pakistan to a historic high of $18 billion during the last fiscal year, which continues to exert pressure on the Pak rupee against other currencies following the huge demand/supply gap. Pakistan imported $60.9 billion worth of goods while its export stood at only $23.22 billion during the last fiscal year, FY18.
Mehar noted: “Other factors such as less inflow of foreign direct investment have also played a crucial role in the weakening of Pakistan’s foreign exchange reserves, which have gone down to $9 billion.”
As the external financing gap keeps rising — it is expected to be remain at $17 to $18 billion during the current fiscal year, FY19 — the country needs substantial external inflows to fulfil its international obligations. “Pakistan needs $10 to $15 billion for external debt servicing alone within the next 16 months,” Muzzamil Aslam said.
Economists say the PTI government will have to take tough economic decisions at home while negotiating for a new IMF bailout program. Tax net expansion, privatization or restructuring of loss-making public sector entities, ease of doing business, and supply of energy without interruption are areas that an incoming government will have to focus on.

Imran Khan’s development promises may face setback if economy keeps worsening, warn economists